Most of the 26 Highwaymen signed in a lower corner, with an initial and a surname, such as “A. Hair” or “H. Newton.” A few signed with their full name. Many scratched the signature into the wet paint, so the letters show as thin lines of the color underneath. Others painted it on in a contrasting color.
Below are close-up photos of signatures for every artist, taken from paintings sold at auction and online. Use them to see what each artist’s hand typically looks like.
What a signature can and cannot tell you
A signature is one clue, not proof. The artists signed differently over the decades, some paintings were never signed, and signatures are a common target for forgers. Some studio practices also blur the picture: Carnell Smith recalled painting parts of works that Alfred Hair signed. Check the board, the frame, the style and the history of the painting too, as described in how to identify an authentic Highwaymen painting. For what paintings sell for, see what Highwaymen paintings are worth.
Watch for close relatives. Several second-generation painters share a surname with one of the 26, such as Kelvin Hair, Roy McLendon Jr. and Tracy Newton, and the Daniels and Newton families each include more than one of the original artists. Read the first initial carefully.
Signatures by artist
Al Black
Signed “A. Black”, in a looping script or in block capitals, usually scratched into the wet paint.



Alphonso Moran
Signed “A. Moran” in tall capitals scratched into the paint, often with a hooked stroke under the A.



Alfred Hair
Signed “A. Hair” in capitals, scratched into the wet paint with a quick stroke, sometimes with a long underline.



Carnell Smith
Signed “C. Smith”, either painted in a strong color such as blue or scratched into the paint, often with an underline.



Charles Walker
Signed with his full name, “Charles Walker”, sometimes with a two-digit year.



Charles Wheeler
Signed “C. Wheeler” in small block capitals, usually painted in a pale color.



Curtis Arnett
Signed with his full name, “Curtis Arnett”, in capitals, sometimes with a two-digit year.



Ellis Buckner
Signed “E. Buckner” in brushed capitals, in dark paint or a pale yellow-green.



George Buckner
Signed “G. Buckner” with a large looped G, often scratched into the paint with an underline.



Harold Newton
Signed “H. Newton” in thin, angular capitals, usually scratched into the paint.



Hezekiah Baker
Signed “H. Baker” in a slanted script, painted or scratched.



Isaac Knight
Signed “I. Knight” or “I. H. Knight” in a flowing script, painted or scratched.



James Gibson
Signed “J. Gibson” in a quick slanted script, usually scratched into the paint.



John Maynor
Signed “J. Maynor” in script, with a looped J.



Johnny Daniels
Signed “J Daniels” in capitals with an underline flourish.



Lemuel Newton
Signed “L. Newton” in capitals, scratched into the paint.



Livingston Roberts
Signed “L. Roberts” in quick, angular letters.



Mary Ann Carroll
Signed “M.A. Carroll”, painted in dark, red or white paint.



R.L. Lewis
Signed “R.L. Lewis” in white capitals.



Robert Butler
Signed with his full name, “Robert Butler”, often with a © mark and a two-digit year.



Rodney Demps
Signed “R. Demps” in heavy black paint.



Roy McLendon
Signed “R.A. McLendon” in capitals.


Sam Newton
Signed “S. Newton” in tall capitals scratched into the paint, sometimes with the year.



Sylvester Wells
Signed “S.M. Wells”, often with an underline flourish.



Willie Daniels
Signed “W. Daniels” in capitals, painted or scratched.



Willie Reagan
Signed “W.C. Reagan” or “W. Reagan”, sometimes with a © mark or a two-digit year.



More Guides
- What Are Florida Highwaymen Paintings Worth?
What drives the price of a Highwaymen painting, with real examples from auctions and Antiques Roadshow, and how to get one appraised.
- How to Identify an Authentic Highwaymen Painting
Who counts as one of the 26, what the paintings are made of, what signatures and paperwork can and cannot tell you, and where to get an expert opinion.
- Where to See Florida Highwaymen Paintings
The Fort Pierce museum and Heritage Trail, and collections in Tallahassee, Orlando and Washington.
- Florida Highwaymen Books and Films
Gary Monroe’s five books and four others, the 2025 feature film, documentaries and radio features, each with where to buy, watch or listen.
