How to Identify an Authentic Highwaymen Painting

Home » Guides » How to Identify an Authentic Highwaymen Painting

No single test proves a Highwaymen painting is genuine. What you can do is check the artist, the materials, the signature and the paperwork, and get an expert opinion before you spend real money. This guide is general information, not an appraisal.

Start with the artist

“Highwaymen” means a specific group: the 26 artists, 25 men and one woman, inducted into the Florida Artists Hall of Fame in 2004. Two other kinds of painting are sold under the name:

If a listing says “style of,” “tribute,” “inspired by” or “second generation,” it is not offering a painting by one of the 26, and the price should reflect that.

Look at what it is painted on

The Highwaymen worked with cheap building supplies, not art-store materials:

Museum records show how the materials changed over time. In the Museum of Florida History’s collection, the paintings by Harold Newton and Alfred Hair are on Upson board, while later works by Al Black (2007), James Gibson (2007) and Mary Ann Carroll (2004) are on Masonite, canvas board and canvas.

The board and frame can tell you whether a painting fits the period claimed for it. They cannot tell you who painted it.

Do not rely on the signature

Not every painting sold as a Highwayman is signed. One 2023 auction lot was an Alfred Hair described as unsigned. And signatures are frequently forged.

It is also not always the whole story. Hair ran something close to a production line, and his brother-in-law Carnell Smith recalled painting skies, water and eventually whole paintings for him. Treat a signature as one piece of evidence.

Be wary of paperwork

Certificates of authenticity are only as good as whoever wrote them. Florida’s Attorney General warns that such a certificate is often worth no more than the paper it is printed on. A note from a relative or a dealer is a claim made by someone with an interest in the sale.

Receipts, family history and old photographs are still worth keeping. Give them to an appraiser as background.

Fakes

Once prices rose, fakes began to appear on eBay. Outright forgeries exist, but the more common problem is a painting by a relative, a follower or an unknown hand, described loosely enough to pass for one of the 26.

Get an expert opinion

Museums generally will not authenticate or appraise a painting for you. A qualified appraiser will. These three professional bodies keep directories:

Choose someone with fine-art credentials who is not also offering to buy the painting.

Checklist

  1. Is the artist one of the 26?
  2. Does the listing say “style,” “tribute,” “inspired” or “second generation”? Then it is not by one of the 26.
  3. Do the board and frame fit the period?
  4. Is there more evidence than a signature?
  5. Who stands behind any certificate?
  6. For a costly piece, have you had an independent written opinion?
  7. Is the price in line with what Highwaymen paintings sell for?

When you are ready, browse the Highwaymen paintings for sale.