What Are Florida Highwaymen Paintings Worth?

Home » Guides » What Are Florida Highwaymen Paintings Worth?

A Highwaymen painting can be worth a few hundred dollars or tens of thousands. It depends on who painted it, what it shows, its condition, and where and when it is sold. This guide explains what moves the price and gives real, dated examples. They are examples, not a price list, and nothing here is an appraisal.

From $25 to five figures

The paintings originally sold for about $25 apiece, often still wet, from the trunks of cars. By 1980 tastes had changed and the trade had all but stopped.

The revival began in the mid-1990s, when Florida art expert Jim Fitch gave the painters the name Highwaymen and a new generation of collectors went looking for their work. Gary Monroe’s first book about them followed in 2001, and prices climbed sharply. Today the best paintings can bring as much as $45,000, though bargains still turn up in thrift shops and at garage sales.

What paintings have sold for

Most originals bring $2,000 to $8,000 at auction, by one auction house’s estimate, and the best go much higher. These published results show the spread.

Antiques Roadshow appraisals

Auction results

Even for one painter the range is wide. The Newton results above run from $7,380 to $45,000.

What drives value

Collectors also weigh a painting’s age, the board it is painted on, whether the frame is original and its history of ownership. No published source puts a number on any of these.

Asking prices are not sale prices

An asking price is what a seller hopes to get. A sale price is what a buyer paid. Auction prices also often run below retail gallery prices. Online listings, ours included, show only asking prices, and only for paintings whose owners chose to list them there.

How to get a painting valued

Decide first why you need a value. A replacement value for insurance and a fair market value for a sale or an estate are different numbers.

For a written appraisal, these three professional bodies keep directories of appraisers:

Avoid any appraiser who charges a percentage of the painting’s value. Some auction houses give a free estimate from photographs, but an estimate from a house that would like to sell your painting is not the same as an independent appraisal.

This guide is general information, not an appraisal or investment advice.

Next steps